Unavoidably, consumers who are shopping for a new cooler compare well-known brands. The majority of people’s short lists will always include Yeti and Engle coolers. These two coolers are famous for a wide variety of reasons, mostly for being the best built and most durable coolers on the market. Engel coolers earned their position in the Cooler Hall of Fame by being the first roto-molded coolers ever produced.
How do you pick between the two prominent brands? Yeti is known for producing high-quality coolers, and Engel is known for creating the first roto-molded cooler.
ENGEL and YETI Coolers in terms of performance
When evaluating the top-rated roto motor coolers on the market, we have tested a lot of Yeti and Engel coolers throughout the years. Our performance evaluations are based on how well these products maintain their ice over a period of five days. For instance, the tundra 45 from Yeti performed substantially worse than the deep blue series 50q cooler from Engel.
Though this might be because the Engle 50q is a bigger cooler. It’s significant to note that less well-known brands of coolers have also outperformed the tundra. Try and work out why we tested the 20q and 25q coolers the Yeti roadie 20q and the Engel 25q performed the same under our test conditions.
We took two coolers from Igloo, the Sportsman series 40q and the Sportsman series 50q, in order to conduct a more thorough analysis. The only difference between the two is their size, and both are created by the same maker using the same materials. According to the notion that larger coolers work better due to their size, the 50q must not perform as well as its smaller sibling.
However, they continued to preserve the ice at the same rate even though this was clearly not the case. What makes the Canyon 35Q more effective at maintaining ice than the Yeti Tundra 45, the Igloo 40, and the Eagle 55Q?
We still don’t fully understand why the tundra did so much worse than the deep blue cooler. We use smaller coolers that perform similarly to the larger ones in every other test. We came to the conclusion that a more scientific method was required, so we took into account the ice-to-size-two ratio in addition to simply comparing cooler sizes.
For instance, when testing a 20 quart cooler, it will keep ice for considerably longer than 60 quarters because 20 kg of ice completely fills the 20 quart cooler. Ice that is packed lasts longer.
The build quality of ENGEL and YETI Coolers
Engel: I’ve been producing premium coolers for almost 50 years. There are many different styles and colours available. The majority of which will have at least 2 inches of insulation and withstand even the coldest temperatures. further provided a standard guarantee of at least 10 years.
Since its introduction in 2006, Yeti coolers have become a popular choice with campers, tailgaters, and series hunters alike. They manufacture their renowned bear-proof coolers with premium materials and even back them with a 5-year warranty.
A little contrast between Engel and Yeti Coolers:
- Made in the USA and The Philippines
- Are more expensive than Engel Coolers
- Roto Molded Design
- Bear proof certification
- Five-Year warranty
- Ice retention for 5 to 7 days
- Made in Thailand
- Cheaper than the Yeti
- Roto molded design
- Bear proof design
- Three-year warranty
- Ice retention of 7 to 10 days
The Top YETI and ENGEL Coolers
The fact that you have a wide range of options will be one of the justifications for purchasing a Yeti cooler or an Engel cooler. Yeti has various sizes and capacities as well as a high ice retention rate. It’s important to keep in mind that whereas Yeti coolers are evaluated by the model size, Engel coolers are rated by the quart capacity.
As a result, the Yeti Tundra 35 can contain 35 quarts of ice. Although not a drawback, it can occasionally be perplexing, especially for those who are familiar with coolers. All Yeti coolers include premium 2-inch polyurethane insulation, and because they are rotomolded in one piece, they also feature the greatest gaskets for sealing.
The deep blue heavy duty cooler is unquestionably the best. Additionally, it has a 2-inch polyurethane insulation as standard, although their silicone freezer gasket seems to beat the yeti’s. You have the option of buying it without non-skid lids or pads.
Many customers appreciate that the cooler’s floor has been slightly angled to provide easier drainage without requiring you to flip it over to empty it. They also consider cooler security, so they provide a variety of ways to secure it to prevent it from toppling over, sliding around, or just being inconvenient while being transported.
Characteristics of a Top-quality Cooler
The following characteristics of a heavy-duty cooler are typical. You’ll do best by paying attention to the following while choosing the best brand and model for yourself:
- Comes with thick insulation as standard
- One that stays full and unopened
- Have airtight seals
- Large capacity
Comes with thick insulation as standard
Since the vast majority of commercially produced coolers employ the same technique for insulation, which involves sandwiching a layer of foam between the exterior and interior walls. For a number of reasons, including the presence of gas bubbles that can transport heat significantly more effectively than solids or liquids, foam serves excellent accident insulation.
Convection is used to transport heat when manufacturing by securing this gas. Second, the amount of heat that can pass from one polymer molecule to another is constrained since the molecules employed in the process are formed of bubbles and are only weakly bound.
It’s crucial to understand that not all foam is created equal and that the foam utilised in the courier buy is still crucial. An open cell or a closed cell can be purchased from a phone. Since the majority of the gas molecules in close-cell foams do not come into contact with one another, they are more stiff and dense.
Open cell foams are thin and flexible, and the gas bubbles easily brush against one another. Less effective than closed cell foam coolers are open cell phone coolers. While closed cell foam is typically loaded with substances that provide a greater level of insulation, such as paint, open cell bubbles may also readily hold water vapour. Recently, there would have been filled with CFCs, but this technique has been phased out as a result of awareness of the harm they cause to the ozone layer and the environment.
One that stays full and unopened
Even while air doesn’t carry heat as well as liquids or solids do, we shouldn’t undervalue its capabilities. Every time you open your cooler, the contents are exposed to the outer, warmer environment. It is simple for fast-moving molecules to enter the cooler and accelerate the already-colder molecules.
The better it will be for your cold beer food and other beverages, the longer you leave your cooler shut.
Have airtight seals
Before making a purchase, you should always inspect the seal on the lid of the cooler. Boat Engel and Yeti coolers are both very good at keeping warm air out and cold air in since they are made out of a single piece of plastic with no seams. This makes them both excellent airtight coolers of the highest quality.
While it is possible to completely fill your cooler so that there are no air pockets inside, doing so is not particularly effective. The ideal mixture will consist of melting water ice mixed with air that is between 32 and 33 degrees Fahrenheit. When you test the temperature, the air will almost always be substantially colder than the ice in the water. The ideal is to have less air pockets, but this will require a lot of labour.
As you can see, the capacity of your cooler directly affects the amount of ice it can hold. It is common knowledge that you must have a 2:1 ratio between the contents of your cooler and your ice. Why don’t you sit down with a calculator and figure this out before bringing your cooler along for the ride?
It is merely a general outline to ensure that it continues to be as effective as feasible. Having said all of that, its surface area has a direct bearing on how far your eyes will melt. Ice cubes melt significantly faster than ice chunks do. As a result, we suggest that you purchase ice blocks to make your own ice blocks, as these will be far more effective at keeping your food and beverages cold.
Additionally, keep in mind that if the ice doesn’t melt, it isn’t completing its duty of dissipating the heat from any heated items you may have in your cooler. Therefore, the amount of labour your eye is exerting to keep your device cold is directly correlated to the rate at which it stinks.
They both meet standards
Due to the fact that both Yeti and Engel have teams of die-hard fans, we are pleased to find that both coolers comfortably meet the requirements needed to be classified as high-quality coolers. Even to the point where an aficionado for Engel coolers gleefully advises you never to waste your money on a Yeti.
However, neither gadget is perfect, and they both have drawbacks. There have been numerous instances of faulty cooler purchases that have been documented. However, both businesses have outstanding guarantees, so if you’re concerned about the quality of your cooler, either one will gladly keep the ice for up to 5 days or longer. If not, the warranty will cover any flaws.
A short web comparison will reveal that Yeti coolers outsell Engel coolers and that angle customers are more satisfied overall. Yes, Yeti coolers outsell Engel coolers in terms of sales, but their prices are lower overall. Owners will still mention how much more expensive it is, but they are happy to explain why. Most people would readily acknowledge that it will be the last cooler you ever purchase.
The Ultimate Challenge
Engel coolers maintained ice for a full 10 days in our most recent cooler ice challenge. Yeti coolers couldn’t duplicate this, though. With just over 9 days, they are not far behind. They are fairly comparable in terms of build quality, however we believe the Yeti’s latching system to be slightly better because the Engel latching technique seems to cause some lid pitting over time.
Its performance was never impacted by the auction; it is merely an aesthetic issue. Though Yetis will scratch more easily, Engel cooler appears to be more robust on the outside assuming you’re accurate about the looks. But these flaws are tiny and shouldn’t worry anyone in the big scheme of things.
At the end of the day, your decision between a Yeti and an Engel will probably come down to price.
Our Final Thoughts
The arguments between owners of Yeti coolers and Engel coolers will carry on endlessly, regardless of what we say in this room today. They have charged Yeti with ripping off Engel concepts, demonstrating the occasionally acrimonious nature of this conflict. The decision would be yours to make and would primarily depend on the budget you indicated above and the features you want in a cooler.
Undoubtedly, Engel coolers are less expensive. The Yeti brand of coolers is more well-known and also lasts longer. So, in our opinion, when you purchase a Yeti cooler, you get what you paid for, including premium construction that is both aesthetically appealing and functional. If you care about your brand or image, you’ll buy a Yeti.
If you’re price conscious, you’ll probably buy the Engel, but since it can keep ice for at least a day longer, you might actually obtain a better device.